Desperately Seeking Closure (…or not?)

the-end

My book ends on a cliff-hanger. This is not a new development, nor is it an accident. I’ve asked around and looked at some opinion polls, including one I conducted myself on the QueryTracker boards, and I know that there are many mixed opinions out there. Some say that it’s lazy. Some say that they are manipulative. Some say they love the suspense of them.

Obviously, I fall into that third category because I have always intended to leave book one open. When I think of successful cliff-hangers, I immediately think of a trilogy that most people I come across haven’t heard of (but it’s one of my all-time favourites for so many reasons). And here they are:

stephen-lawhead-song-of-albion-trilogy

The Paradise War trilogy by Stephen R Lawhead. I can’t adequately express my love for these books, but the main point for this post is the ending of the second book. It ends on the BEST cliff-hanger I have ever read, and it is one of the things that inspired me to use that device in my own work. There is no warning, no apology, explanation… it ends with a jaw-dropping pulse-racing moment and it just DROPS you. (Keep in mind that when I read it, the third book was still a year away from its pub date – talk about torture!) A little difference, of course, is that he is a master storyteller, and I am writing my debut novel. Something to aspire to, for sure, but what if I’m not there yet?

And that’s what I’m now wondering. Am I being lazy with my ending? I certainly don’t feel like that’s what I’m doing. I want to tell a bigger story than one novel, and I love ending in a way that leaves you thirsty for the next installment.

But then I read the ending of Divergent. Or Pivot Point. They’re both the beginning of trilogies, and their stories continue past the endings of these books. But while they leave a few questions open, they don’t end on cliff-hangers. They end. They have satisfying endings in and of themselves, even while you’re waiting for the rest of the story. You want to keep reading because of the world, or the characters, or the bigger story that’s ongoing. But if you stopped reading after that first book, you’d be okay. You’d have a story that felt complete.

So which is better?

Advertisements

2 thoughts on “Desperately Seeking Closure (…or not?)

  1. This is such a tough one! As a debut author, I don’t think you can get away with it – at least not for the first book in the series. And even with proven authors, I’m not a fan of cliffhanger endings. It’s sort of been a trend in the last few years, and it’s changed the way I read. I actually don’t even start a series anymore until all the books are out. Partly because of the potential cliffhanger issue, and also because I hate waiting for books to come out. =) I wouldn’t call ending with a cliffhanger lazy, but I do think it will make it harder for an agent to sell to a publisher.

    Like

  2. Thanks Karyne! I’ve been thinking along the same lines – debut author, first book in the series – it’s a tough order. I really do love my ending, but I think I need to wrap it up a little neater. It’s funny, my niece just started reading in earnest in the last two years, and she is the same way. She won’t start a series if it’s not complete first. I just can’t do that! As difficult as it is to wait for the next installment, if there’s a book out there I’m dying to read, I’ve gotta read it! And ESPECIALLY if there are going to be spoilers out there before I’m done reading. Un. Acc. Ept. Able. When HP7 came out I bought it at midnight and holed up in my apartment for the weekend until I was done. Bad example cos it was the end of the series and there were no more, but good example for the lengths I’ll go to for avoiding spoilers.
    All this, and I should probably also mention that I’m 99% certain I’m self-publishing so I don’t have to worry about the agent/publisher angle. A good point though! 🙂

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s